
Here’s a long excerpt from an article by an oncologist that you may find interesting. Highly recommended if you’re using CAM (complemtary and alternative medicine) treatments for cancer:
WHEN I WAS TRAINING in medical oncology at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center here in New York, patients arriving for their appointments would get a clipboard with a few forms to fill out. One of the forms asked to list all the medications they were taking, including supplements. Some patients had so many that they would run out of space on the form and had to continue on reverse. I would always go through the supplements one by one. “Why are you taking this one,” I would ask. “And this one?” The answers were never clear.
Over the next few months, ETP News will be publishing several stories in a series we call “Selling Hope.” It is about financial incentives in healthcare more broadly, and particularly in cancer care.
This is Chapter I: Going Undercover.
***
We do not have good statistics on how many cancer patients in the US use “complementary and alternative” treatments, defined by the National Cancer Institute as those “not thought of as standard medical care.” Some studies say a third, some say more than half. They can range from vitamins, herbs, mushrooms, diets and fasting to coffee enemas, unapproved immunotherapies and things that even oncologists like myself have never heard of, like “extracorporeal blood ozonation.”
Rather than focusing on why patients choose these questionable treatments, I asked a different question – who are the doctors prescribing them? By “prescribing” I mean that the clinician writes in their clinical note, for example, “Take berberine, two capsules twice a day,” whether an actual prescription is needed or not.
How many doctors do this? To answer this question, we would have to dig into clinical notes – a herculean task. Even more of a mystery is what these doctors tell their patients – that’s not recorded anywhere. Are they upfront about the dubious benefits of these remedies? Do they warn patients of the risks? What if someone else prescribed it, or the patient is self-medicating – do they still bring it up, or turn a blind eye?
For supplements – I will use the term broadly to refer to any complementary or alternative medication taken by mouth or injection – the risks include not only their own side effects, but also drug-drug interactions. The supplement can make another drug (chemotherapy, antinausea medications, antibiotics, blood-thinners, etc) more toxic or less effective. Or the supplement and chemotherapy may cause “overlapping” side effects affecting the same organ, for example the liver. In a 2021 study by Dr Richard Lee, who now directs the Integrative Medicine program at the City of Hope Medical Center, about 80% of cancer patients receiving supplements were at risk for major drug-drug interactions.
During my time at MSKCC, our guidance to patients was simple: if the supplement is “food,” for example an herbal tea, you may continue taking it. If it is a medicine, for example if it comes in a pill bottle, don’t take it while you are on chemotherapy.
At UCSF’s Osher Center for Integrative Health, if the patient is combining supplements with chemotherapy, oncologists order an “eConsult,” sending the patient’s information to an expert pharmacist to assess the potential risks of this particular combination. It takes the pharmacist on average 1-2 hours of research, sometimes more, to provide the answer, according to a recent presentation by Dr. Kavita K. Mishra, the Center’s Clinical Director.
To see first-hand how and why these supplements are prescribed to patients, I went undercover, posing as a cancer patient myself. I prepared a fake colonoscopy report showing that I was diagnosed with colon cancer, a CT scan report showing liver metastases, and an imaginary oncologist’s note recommending chemotherapy.
I then saw a series of clinicians.

